| Pier
1 Imports (PIR) May Have Finally Bottomed Out |
Published: November 7, 2005
------------------------------------------------
Pier 1 Imports (PIR, $12.00)
------------------------------------------------
Pier
1 Imports (PIR)
Sector = Services
Industry = Home Furnishing Stores
Market Cap. = $1.0 billion
Enterprise Value = $939 million
2004 Revenues = $1.9 billion
2004 Gross Profit = $727.3 million
2004 Revenue Growth = +1.6%
Insider Ownership = 1.3%
Institutional Ownership = 86.1%
Insider Activity (ttm) = Neutral
Enterprise Value/EBITDA = 9.4 |
Pier 1 is a leading retailer of
furniture, baskets, candles, and a related selection of handcrafted home
décor merchandise. The company imports more than 4,000 functional and
decorative houseware products from forty different countries. It then
distributes these products through a chain of nearly 1,200 retail stores
nationwide.
For value investors that prefer to search for beaten-up turnaround
candidates, Pier 1 could fit the bill. The company has tried one
approach after another to turn its operations around over the past
couple years, and nothing seems to have worked. Marketing spokespersons
such as Kirstie Alley and Thom Filicia have been ineffective, inventory
overhauls have failed to connect with consumers, languishing items have
only been moved through margin-slashing markdowns, and same-store sales
have declined for eighteen consecutive quarters. As a result, the
company has been forced to lower its earnings outlook 12 times in the
past twelve months.
Last week, the company announced a sharp -10.4% drop in October
same-store sales. Management also added that recent promotional activity
would weigh heavily on third-quarter margins.
| John
DiStanislao's undervalued investing ideas have delivered extraordinary
returns since he began working for StreetAuthority several
months ago. Thanks to gains of +146.8% on CTTY, +46.5% on
JOB, +45.1% on HGGR, and many others in just a few short
months, John has quickly established himself as one of the
best-performing newsletter analysts in the country. Visit
the link below to try John DiStanislao's
premium value-oriented newsletter -- Margin-of-Safety
Investing -- at zero cost and with zero obligation for a full 30
days.
|
|
Although the firm's recent
results have been unusually bleak, all turnaround stories must reach
bottom somewhere before they can begin to climb higher. Those with the
faith to climb aboard before signs of a recovery emerge are typically
rewarded for their foresight. To that end, the company has been upgraded
by five different brokerage firms over the past three months, and Warren
Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway purchased eight million shares of the firm
last year -- taking a hefty 9% stake.
While some of Pier One's weakness is attributable to company-specific
issues, others in the industry have reported soft results as well. For
example, Cost Plus has posted a -3% drop in same-store sales this year.
Cost Plus is also experiencing problems with inventory buildup, as
merchandise growth outpaced sales gains last quarter 21% to 7%. And
markdowns of slow-moving merchandise also took a bite out of Bombay's
recent results, with second-quarter net losses widening from $6.3
million to $9.4 million.
As the table below clearly illustrates, PIR has underperformed its
industry peers for the past five years:
| Return
Period |
PIR |
Industry
Avg. |
| 1-Month |
+6.9% |
+6.8% |
| 3-Month |
-13.9% |
-8.7% |
| YTD |
-39.1% |
-4.5% |
| 1-Year |
-35.6% |
-7.3% |
| 3-Year |
-12.3% |
+6.4% |
| 5-Year |
-0.7% |
+11.7% |
Not surprisingly, this pullback
has made valuation levels for PIR difficult to value investors to
ignore. This is true not only relative to PIR's rivals, but also with
respect to the stock's historical averages. For example, the shares are
currently trading at a Price/Sales ratio of just 0.48 -- precisely half
of the five-year average of 0.96. The current Price/Book of 1.40 is also
cheap by historical standards.
The recent share price correction has also made the company's dividend
yield stand out, particularly for yield-hungry investors. After lifting
its dividend payout in each of the past five years, Pier 1 is currently
handing out an annual dividend of $0.38 per share, which equates to a
yield of approximately 3.4%. However, given the extreme payout ratio and
declining cash flows, it should be noted that this $35 million annual
distribution could be cut if the firm's bottom line doesn't begin to
improve.
Still, the company's sizable cash balance -- which is expected to reach
nearly $170 million at the end of the year -- could buy it some time as
management searches for ways to reconnect with shoppers and improve
sluggish store traffic. Until then, a generous stock repurchase program
should help improve per-share results, and could be a prudent use of
capital at these low prices.
Although the macroeconomic environment is challenging and competition
may keep a lid on margins, now may be the time to take a closer look at
Pier One. Given the level of negativity and pessimism built into the
shares, further bad news is liable to be shrugged off, and any
improvements could easily lead to a sharp advance in the shares --
possibly leading to a short-covering rally (13% of the company's shares
are currently sold short).
To that end, management has revamped its merchandise yet again, is
running new television commercials, and has distributed the company's
first-ever fall catalog to more than 3 million homes. It takes time for
any new strategy to take hold. However, those with the patience to wait
on these initiatives to produce results may find the current oversold
situation at Pier 1 intriguing.
---------------------
Important Note: The above article was merely a small excerpt
from a recent issue we sent to subscribers of our premium value investing service --
Margin-of-Safety
Investing. In each issue of that newsletter, editor John
DiStanislao delivers an in-depth look at a variety of deeply discounted
stocks that should provide investors with a solid margin of safety at
current prices. To receive your copy of our most recent issue of Margin-of-Safety
Investing, as well as other guidance similar to
this twice per month, you'll need to register for this separate publication.
To learn more, please visit the following link:
https://www.streetauthority.com/subscribe-msi.asp
-----------------------------
Important Note: The above article
was merely a small excerpt from a recent issue we sent to subscribers of
our premium value investing service -- Margin-of-Safety
Investing. In each issue of that newsletter, editors Nathan
Slaughter and Paul Tracy deliver an in-depth look at a variety of other deeply discounted
stocks that should provide investors with a solid margin of safety at
current prices. To receive your copy of our most recent issue of Margin-of-Safety
Investing, as well as other guidance similar to this twice per
month, you'll need to subscribe to this publication. To learn more,
please visit:
https://www.streetauthority.com/subscribe-msi.asp
Thanks for reading!
|


Nathan Slaughter
Editor
Half-Priced Stocks, The ETF Authority
|
| To receive
in-depth guidance on today's leading value opportunities every other weekend, plus educational guidance, please subscribe to
Nathan Slaughter & Paul Tracy's premium value investing newsletter --
Half-Priced
Stocks |
|
|

|
Income Security
of the Month
Our "Income Security of the Month" for August 2008 invests in a
fast-growing overseas market that doesn't get much exposure in the
mainstream financial press. And although it typically makes enormous
annual dividend payments -- it has paid an average dividend of
25.5% per year over the past five years -- this fund is perhaps
most appealing for its total return potential. Specifically, the
fund has delivered total returns of +178.9% since 2003,
and it ranks in the top 10% of its category over the past decade.
|
Top
10 Stocks for 2008!
Since we began publishing this report back in 2003, the picks we've
featured have consistently beaten the broader market -- delivering average
gains of +21.3% per year and outperforming the S&P by a nearly
2-to-1 margin. Act now to reserve your copy of our newest report -- Top
Ten Stocks for 2008. |