Lesson
#6 -- Collar & Butterfly Trades
There
are two final strategies that options investors should be aware of: collars and
butterflies. Although these two are not as widely used as the other strategies
we've detailed previously (please see lessons #1-5 for details), they can often
prove very useful when the situation is right.
Collar
A collar is an interesting strategy that is often employed by major investment
banks and corporate executives. This position is made by selling a call option
at one strike price and using the proceeds to purchase a put option at a lower
price. The cost to the investor to make this trade, therefore, is essentially
zero.
Investors who hold a large position in an underlying stock and
wish to liquidate their holdings at some time in the future commonly use this
type of trade. Why? Well, the collar allows them to lock in a particular sale
price (in actuality, it ends up being a range between two prices) ahead of time.
In other words, after implementing the collar trade, they then know the exact
highest and lowest dollar amounts they could potentially receive when they sell
their underlying stock. Speculators do not commonly make this type of trade
since it is a high-risk, low-reward scenario unless you hold the underlying
stock. However, if the investor already owns the underlying stock, then the
trade is very low-risk and low-cost.
Example:
Judy is an executive at IBM and has recently been awarded a significant amount
of IBM stock, which is currently trading at $100. She feels strongly about
IBM’s prospects over the next three months, but she remembers that many other
people who worked at high-tech firms had the same belief in the 1990s when the
Internet bubble collapsed. Most of these people lost virtually all of their
investment. In this particular case, however, Judy cannot afford to lose her
entire investment. On the other hand, she would also like to try to get $10 more
for per share her stock, or $110.
After assessing her personal financial situation, Judy
determines that she cannot afford to sell her shares for anything less than $90.
To hedge her current holdings, she decides to institute a collar trade. (This
trade gets its name because the position is essentially "collared"
between two prices.) It is currently January, and to collar this position for
three months she sells one IBM MAR 120 call for every 100 shares she owns. With
the amount she receives from this sale she simultaneously buys one IBM MAR 80
put for every 100 shares that she owns (we will assume that both sides cost $5
each). Since both of these options cost the same price, the net cost of this
initial trade was $0 to her. With this trade, Judy now knows that no matter what
happens, she will receive an amount between $90 and $110 if she decides to sell
her IBM shares when the options expire in March.

As the graph above illustrates, Judy's total profit or loss
from the combinations of these positions is limited to $10. This means that if
IBM rockets up to $200, the most Judy will receive is $110. Conversely, if IBM
crashes to $20, the least she will receive is $90. For an investor who is
comfortable with either of the two scenarios, this is an excellent hedging
strategy.
Butterfly
Traders often use the butterfly strategy when they feel a particular stock will
remain neutral during a certain period. By entering into a butterfly trade, the
trader is essentially betting that the underlying stock price will remain close
to where it is currently. This trade requires three separate positions (four
total contracts), and is therefore a bit more complex than the collar. It can be
made using either put options or call options. For simplicity, we will use calls
in this example. To execute this trade, the investor will need to buy two calls
-- one at a low strike price and one at a higher strike price. The investor also
needs to sell two options with strike prices at or near the current price. In
the end, this type of trade will pay the maximum amount if the stock finishes at
the middle strike price. The trade has very limited downside risk, but the
trader must estimate the correct future stock price to a fairly narrow range in
order to make the trade profitable.
Example:
An investor believes that IBM, which is once again trading at $100, will remain
relatively unchanged during the next month. To take advantage of this, but also
desiring to limit downside risk, the trader sets up a butterfly trade. To do
this, the trader buys one IBM 95 call for $6 and one IBM 105 call for $1. The
trader will also sell two IBM 100 calls for $3 each. The net result of all of
these positions will be a cost of just $1 to the trader, as shown below:
|
Option Trade
|
Cost |
| Sell 2 IBM 100 calls |
+$6 |
| Buy 1 IBM 95 call |
-$6 |
| Buy 1 IBM 105 call |
-$1 |
| Total |
-$1 |

A butterfly trade may seem complicated at first glance due to
the large number of options positions required to construct it. However, a quick
look at the diagram above should make the payoff relatively easy to understand.
In this example, the trader obtains the maximum payoff when the stock finishes
at $100. As IBM's price moves further and further from $100 in either direction,
the trade begins to lose value. When the price reaches (or moves beyond) $95 or
$105, the trade then leads to a maximum loss of $1. This diagram clearly shows
just how accurate the trader must be at forecasting IBM's future stock price in
order to reap a profit from the trade. If the outcome does not go according to
plan, however, then the worst that can happen is the trader loses $1, no matter
how high or low the price goes.
Conclusion
The two options strategies outlined above -- the collar and the butterfly --
should only be used in very specific situations. However, when used effectively,
they can be extremely profitable. A collar can help lower your volatility during
an uncertain time period and can help you lock in a range of sale prices for a
stock you currently own. Meanwhile, the butterfly is a good strategy for periods
where a stock is not likely to fluctuate to a great degree. The butterfly trade
can change what would normally be an unprofitable trading period for the stock
into a profitable one.
Please visit the link below to view our final options trading
lesson. In it, we'll introduce you to the two most important components of
an option's value--intrinsic value and time value.
-- Jeff Bishop
Staff Writer
StreetAuthority.com
Income Security
of the Month
Our "Income Security of the Month" for August 2008 invests in a
fast-growing overseas market that doesn't get much exposure in the
mainstream financial press. And although it typically makes enormous
annual dividend payments -- it has paid an average dividend of
25.5% per year over the past five years -- this fund is perhaps
most appealing for its total return potential. Specifically, the
fund has delivered total returns of +178.9% since 2003,
and it ranks in the top 10% of its category over the past decade.
|
Top
10 Stocks for 2008!
Since we began publishing this report back in 2003, the picks we've
featured have consistently beaten the broader market -- delivering average
gains of +21.3% per year and outperforming the S&P by a nearly
2-to-1 margin. Act now to reserve your copy of our newest report -- Top
Ten Stocks for 2008. |